He tells Erin to get over the fact that he turned her down for a date and storms off. The dad shaming was not limited to social media. He later goes with Darryl and Dwight on a trip to a bookstore, and they later have fun at a local roller skating rink. In " The Whale ", Andy, still sailing to the Bahamas, communicates with Erin and several of his co-workers. In " Murder ", Andy asks Erin out on a date while playing a game called Belles, Bourbon, and Bulletsbut is confused whether she was just playing along with the game.
This is evidenced later in " Did I Stutter?
Andy admits this as he doesn't want to see the printer fire cause a catastrophe to a school or hospital, but finds himself harassed throughout the day by the sales staff when they all suspect he did it. However, Andy tells her he's dating someone, and she is shocked to hear they've been out on 31 dates so far. Between season four and five, Andy plans his wedding with Angela, although his ideas are often rejected by her.
He decides to hire their exes such as Alice Collette Wolfea marketing consultant and Gabe to the branch in a bid to make Erin and Pete uncomfortable.